So the 2nd day we're in and the heater broke. I didn't have much time to decide. I thought about something that would save energy and give us a tax credit, but that would take longer to install and we were staying at my in-laws in the interim. Ack. I know. So I went with the Temp Star 150,000 BTU 80% Furnace and 410A A-coil. Sorry I couldn't find a photo.
Also, Air & Water has a choose the right heater buying guide. Check it out: